| Platinum | Mitten Raised |
| Gold | Crumbl |
| Gold | Flour Child Bakery |
| Gold | Insomnia Cookies |
| Silver | Wildflour Cookie Co. |
| Bronze | Grand Traverse Pie Co. |
| Top Pick | Bake N' Cakes |
| Top Pick | Coco's Confections |
| Top Pick | Cookies With Sass, Saint Johns |
| Top Pick | Kikis Cookies St. Johns |