| Platinum | Flour Child Bakery |
| Gold | Everything Is Cheesecake |
| Silver | Mr. Leslie's Cheesecakes |
| Bronze | Bake N' Cakes |
| Top Pick | Babe's Corner |
| Top Pick | Cakes-A-Bloomin' |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen (Treat) |
| Top Pick | Park Lake Creamery |
| Top Pick | Sweet Encounter Bakery & Cafe |
| Top Pick | That New Place |