| Platinum | Olympic Broil |
| Gold | Chick-fil-A |
| Silver | East Side Fish Fry |
| Bronze | Buffalo Wild Wings |
| Top Pick | Finger Lickin Chicken & Fish |
| Top Pick | Grand Grillin |
| Top Pick | Joe's Gizzard City |
| Top Pick | Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Ya Ya's Flame Broiled Chicken |