| Platinum | Flour Child Bakery |
| Gold | Goodfellas Bagel Deli |
| Silver | The New Daily Bagel |
| Bronze | Bruegger's Bagels |
| Top Pick | Arms & Embers |
| Top Pick | Bangos |
| Top Pick | Big Apple Bagels |
| Top Pick | Dunkin' |
| Top Pick | Einstein Bros. Bagels |
| Top Pick | Village Ice Cream & Cafe |