| Platinum | MSU Dairy Store |
| Gold | Mooville Ice Cream |
| Silver | The Daily Scoop Ice Cream Shoppe |
| Bronze | Sweet Sensations |
| Top Pick | Arctic Corner Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Corner Cone |
| Top Pick | Dairy Dan |
| Top Pick | iScream |
| Top Pick | Quality Dairy Store |
| Top Pick | Scoopy Doo's Old Fashioned Ice Cream |